A Question Of Good

@hatescorsets continued from [x]

Weatherby gave a soft click of his tongue, an automatic disapproval – less for her choice and more for her apparent opinion toward where his objections lay. “It is not a question of his character Elizabeth. Were it so simple as that I would have no argument in this quarter.” Indeed, young Turner had grown up to be a perfectly respectable young man – and even if he hadn’t, Weatherby supposed it would hardly matter once his daughter locked herself on to him. 

“I will not press you to change your mind,” He assured, having no desire for such an argument and knowing full well Theodosia would never have stood for him trying to dissuade their daughter from pursuing her happiness, were she here beside him now. 

“But a word of caution, my dear. Your choice will not be well received by our peers in London – and it will not behoove you to argue too heavily the merits of a blacksmith among politicians and their daughters. We may have certain freedoms here in the new world, but our obligations to the old one still stand. The time will come when we will be bid to entertain them, and if we wish to maintain our positions which afford us such liberties as these, we will need to remain beyond reproach. Scandals come and scandals go, but no politician I have ever met, has ever forgotten an insult.” 

name / nickname(s): holmes
pronouns: fluid. he / him predominantly 
( main ) active blogs: you’re looking at it. also @oceanmotioned is a resource run by me.
Watching and / or reading rn:
currently watching disenchantment with @tidefated

ideal superpower: 100% self sufficiency  
animal you would want to be turned into: a loved cat
fictional character you would most like to meet irl:
never meet your heroes
book/show/movie you loved as a kid and still love today: harry potter probably
book/show/movie you think is underappreciated: hornblower!
favorite thing to do on a rainy day:
reading / writing / watching netflix
favorite season: autumn. i like the colors.
favorite holiday: privateer days
star wars or star trek:
 i literally cannot tell the difference
marvel or dc: marvel
parks and rec or the office: havent seen either, ‘camera of the office’ meme is good tho
favorite superhero: tia dalma
favorite disney princess: mulan

tagged by: @britanniam

tagging: @brassandblue / @corsicangeneral / @harriedwritings​ / @hatescorsets​ / @intolerablexsacrifice​ / @least-among-hamiltons​ / @parlley / @quiauhxochitl / @tidefated​ / if you see it snag it like a proper pirate and @ me!

answer the following for so people know how shipping works on your blog.

REPOST. don’t reblog.
TAGGED BY:  I am robbing my old blogs again don’t mind me
TAGGING: @harriedwritings​ / @hatescorsets​ / @intolerablexsacrifice​ / @least-among-hamiltons​ / @lightsailing / @parlley / @quiauhxochitl / @tidefated​ / if you see it snag it like a proper pirate and @ me!

WHAT’S YOUR OTP FOR YOUR MUSE?:

  • Jack Sparrow: On the blog I write Jack with @tidefated‘s Armando and ( sort of ) his Cutler as well, so there’s that. I also love Jack with Esmeralda and Arabella, as well as several different OC’s ( some of which are my own design I will admit, though I will stan Jack & Nadifa til I perish ) Another big one is Sparrington, of course!

  • Horatio Hornblower: I ship Horatio with @tidefated‘s everybody on some level, honestly xD I also ship him with @lightsailing‘s Edrington ( platonic / frienemies / romantic even ) and in general I do love him with Edward, William & Andre! 

  • Abigail Ashe: She’s pretty attached to @tidefated‘s Joji and doesn’t appear interested in budging on that front any time soon.

  • Thomas Hamilton: @intolerablexsacrifice‘s Flint is the Only James To Exist as far as this gremlin is concerned, and of course he adores @harriedwritings‘ Miranda. I wish it would stop there but he is horrendous so naturally not. He’s honestly likely to pair up with anyone mad enough to dare, if they know his history with Flint.

  • Graham Hume: @tidefated‘s Billy & Edward have managed to snag him, though I honestly could not say who else he would pair off with? He has secret formulas to his tastes I have not yet managed to decipher.

  • John Silver: @tidefated‘s Billy is literally the only person to successfully romance him roleplay wise. I would kill for Madi, though boy howdy they have work to do and with my Silver being – the Jandro mess he is, uh. Uh. Good luck I guess? I literally have no idea who else. Maybe @intolerablexsacrifice but only because Malakh hates fanon Silver/Flint with the same amount of passionate vitriol as I do and it would be delightfully spitefully ironic.

  • Charles Vane: Heck. @tidefated has this boy by the coarse hairs I won’t lie. Abraham, Billy, Cutler, Edward, Joji, Max & William all have his love. Mind you with Max that’s 100% a platonic thing ( see nOTP’s ) He’d probably roll with @intolerablexsacrifice if Thomas willed it. He’d probably roll with @theypissedonme just cause they’re mates and he’s – like that, I guess. @harriedwritings Miranda, absolutely. 

  • Andre Cotard: Andre doesn’t get out much but he stans Edward, Horatio, & William.

  • Jane de Bac: Any man who can pick her up and is smart enough fucking not to has a good chance with her honestly, provided he’s not a goddamn idiot and is perfectly able to take orders from her if necessary. If he cannot respect the position she has built for herself, she has no interest. And if he is interested in profiting off her, well – that will not last long. She will not abide by having men scheming to take her power from her, mark me on that. So, provided he is a little revolutionary, doesn’t mind the fact she comes with three sprogs and a very demanding career in both high society and commerce, he is more than welcome to try. 

  • Theodore Groves: Literally anyone who can tolerate him for 10+ days lmfao. His biggest ship is with @lightsailing‘s Lord Edrington – he has nothing canonically and honestly I am okay with that. I think if he turned to anyone from his own story ( Aside of course, from my own Gillette, whom he does pair off with on occasion ) it would probably be Norrington. But yknow what he is also a total freak of nature so he might go for Davy too. He’s that wierdo who thinks the way the beard clings to anything that pokes near it is adorable so I mean. Who knows at this point with this duck.

  • Weatherby Swann: His beloved and departed wife Theodosia. Who I really need to write more about. Bad me.

  • Loki Friggajarson: Calypso ( & Davy, honestly. Terrible trio. ) Poseidon. Probably Armando if he got the chance at it. William Bush most likely. Probably Billy & Joji. Flint, Thomas and Miranda would be a fucking romp okay he would love the three of them so much, a bundle of spitfires, he’d be absolutely delighted. Probably Charles Vane. RIP the universe on that front. And idk – try him, he’s very mutable.

  • Derek Morgan: Derek is the epitome of homebody so he really needs someone who can shake his whole world up – man or woman, he’s flexible and he could really use some eye opening experiences. Also, somebody get this damn man some landlegs?!

  • Severus Snape: Honestly Severus is a hard cookie to crumble. I’ve been writing him the longest out of all my muses ( as my first canon muse, I’ve been writing him since 1999 and my only regret is I didn’t leave the fandom and start writing him like this sooner ) but when it comes to romance he is prickly and really needs time to get to know someone first. He doesn’t form attraction based on physical features but rather on intellect and engagement – if you can’t stimulate him mentally, he won’t bother with you sexually, which means going for him means going for the long haul on top of it. That said, he is flexible when it comes to gender so I mean, have at him. 

WHAT ARE YOU WILLING TO RP WHEN IT COMES TO SHIPPING?:
My big thing is that I prefer relationships where the characters learn and grow together. It doesn’t have to be easy – in fact it bores me when it is – but it also doesn’t have to be a fight 24/7 either. I like looking at everything – from the small domestic moments, to the epiphanies that are drawn in the light of arguments or even discussions, to the physical and emotional tensions, all the way to how this relationship impacts other relationships, because I don’t believe these characters exist in a bubble and I love exploring what other characters think and feel about relationships as they form. For me a ship is as much about development as anything else, romantic elements included certainly, but if a character doesn’t learn anything, if the two just stagnate together – that’s no fun. I am all about characters that push and pull one another to do better or fall farther and it’s always a delightful entanglement. 

HOW LARGE DOES THE AGE GAP HAVE TO BE TO MAKE IT UNCOMFORTABLE?:
Fun fact. If a character is a consenting adult over the age of twenty one – I do not have a point of discomfort. I have been writing in fandom for nineteen years, which means I grew up back when internet safety rules were a thing and fandom spaces were generally understood to be run by adults, for adults – long before the ideas of puritanism and content policing. Which means I have been writing 20-40 year olds with Ancient As Balls immortals for longer than some people on this platform have been breathing.

I have been writing age gaps with the understanding that a consenting adult is allowed to make their own choices, for good or for ill, for long enough to have lost all concept of a fuck to give about what it looks like in the real world, because rather like Thomas Harris, I am capable of writing something questionable without toting it as my personal morality outside of explorational fiction. I am no more interested in dating a 1200 year old ( or 70 year old ) than Harris is interested in consuming human flesh and tricking the police into joining him for dinner. 

ARE YOU SELECTIVE WHEN SHIPPING?:
Kinda sorta not really but also yes. Confused? Me too. 

So to make this a little more clear. If I have 0 chemistry with you on an ooc level ( we don’t talk to one another outside of memes, there’s no headcanon exchanges, we aren’t yelling at one another at odd hours of the morning about this or that ) chances are you could play the best rendition of my favorite character in the whole fandom – and I won’t ship it because I am far too terrified to get invested. 

Alternatively if we’re interacting then I will follow your lead – if you express interest chances are I am already down. I never want to push people in this regard, but I am always clear when I do not want to have this discussion and it usually involves me starting with: I get the appeal but personally, it isn’t something I ship. 

I will never lead you on in this regard, but I may be far too shy or fucking nervous out of my mind to outright say ‘Hey, I ship this, would you want to explore it’ because my brain is full of gremlins. Sorry about that. 

HOW FAR DO STEAMY MOMENTS HAVE TO GO BEFORE THEY’RE CONSIDERED NSFW?:
If clothes are on I still count it as PG-13 no matter how much heavy petting is going on outside of them so I mean my spectrum is fairly broad. I don’t put anything under a readmore, dick and dyson jokes are common here, and it isn’t entirely improbable that characters may be getting spicy under the sheets ( or on top of desks / wherever happens to be convenient ) but for the most part I don’t really consider it NSFW unless there is some heavier descriptions personally. That said because I am aware this account has people who watch it for some raisin, I will tag anything from a dick joke to a full on dysoning from here to high heaven just to be safe. 

WHO ARE OTHER MUSES YOU SHIP YOUR MUSE WITH?:
I pretty much answered this in OTP’s but honestly I will ship my characters with anyone whom they can form something organic and healthy with. If it feels like something we can get invested in I will not hesitate. 

ANY NOTPS?:

  • Jack Sparrow: Elizabeth Swann, Will Turner, Carina Smyth, Henry Turner & Christophe
  • Horatio Hornblower: Aside from forced heteronormativity, no. 
  • Abigail Ashe: aksjhd Ned Low 150% Also Flint because Big Nopes
  • Thomas Hamilton: There probably should be but he is horrendous so…oh. Abigail. 
  • Graham Hume: Dufrense probably, other than that he’s not the pickiest fellow
  • John Silver: Flint. Especially fanon Flint. No. Just no.
  • Charles Vane: Eleanor. Max. Anne. Let them love women jfc. Also Blackbeard, omfg.
  • Andre Cotard: Napoleon probably idfk he doesn’t get out much.
  • Jane de Bac: Aside from arrogant shit for brains, not really.
  • Theodore Groves: Barbossa probably. 
  • Weatherby Swann: Anyone who is not Theodosia tbh.
  • Loki Friggajarson: Thor ffs, & anyone he holds familial bond with jfc.
  • Derek Morgan: Rossi & Straus
  • Severus Snape: Anything Death Eater or Marauder shaped. Lily. 

DOES ONE HAVE TO ASK TO SHIP WITH YOU?:
I am a very dumb barnacle so if you do not tell me you think our characters could be interesting together I will not know that you think this and shall play platonic cause I don’t want to bother you and its a big circle of suck 9 / 10 times so really if you’re interested just peep at me in DM and we can hash it out. 

HOW OFTEN DO YOU LIKE TO SHIP?:
Obligatory age of sail joke here, I am literally always shipping in one way or another. IDK escapist fantasy and fun romps through impossible relationships is my jam, and seeing as I’m not making money doing it, I can’t even say so sue me.

ARE YOU MULTISHIP?:  
I literally dock an armada, so big yup.

ARE YOU SHIP OBSESSED OR SHIP MORE-OR-LESS?:
Is this not the same as how often? Uh – idk I wouldn’t say I am obsessed? I do love romantic storylines whether they are angst ridden or fluffy but I can also thrive of platonic friendships and civil rivalries so I mean? IDK what to say here actually lmao.

WHAT IS YOUR FAVORITE SHIP IN YOUR CURRENT FANDOM?:
Character x Agency & Happiness

FINALLY, HOW DOES ONE SHIP WITH YOU?:
Poke me. Fling me a meme. Ask me. Slap me with a fish. Whatever floats your boat.

❝ My quartermaster is the literal bane of my existence. ❞ [ @ t.ham in uhhh fuck i dont even remember verse names but HE’S TALKING ABOUT SILVER SO ]

{ Shit To Say Meme }

“So have him replaced.” Thomas responded idly enough, “There are other crew favorites are there not? Certainly more capable sailors among them – surely he is likable, but that hardly qualifies him for the role. I’m sure with the right words in the right ears you could have him deposed in a week or so if you were truly adamant about it.”

“I’m just–” James cuts off, hesitating. “–afraid. Afraid he won’t come back, afraid he /will/. Just afraid.” [ @ abigail in That Verse ]

{ Shit To Say Meme }

Abigail supposed in some ways, the nerves that Mister McGraw could exhibit were quite charming, especially when one considered precisely what he was capable of. She wondered idly if perhaps he had forgotten the core bond between them, how deeply ensnared it was in his fate and that of Mister Hamilton’s, but in the end she supposed it didn’t matter. So long as he allowed his fear to cage him like this, there would be no hope for happy endings.

“You’re Captain Flint – or have you forgotten that part of yourself, holed up here all alone with your fear and your sadness for so long?” Rising to her feet, Abigail paced the small confines of the earthbare kitchen floor, agitation in the flick of her wrist through the air, cutting across all interruption as her other hand found purchase at her hip while she strode along, expounding on her point. 

For good or for ill, surrender was not a look that suited this man and she was quite through with bearing witness to it. “It’s been nearly a decade or more – certainly I cannot account for feelings held so dear, let alone the sort which have accumulated the grief and guilt that these carry – but has it not occurred to you in your isolation that maybe the reason he doesn’t come is because he doesn’t know how? Think of it from his perspective for a moment!”

She turned, finally facing him, “While you were out here fighting and waging war on account of his memory, he was toiling day and night, surviving on the hope that you and his wife were happy. But you’re not – you weren’t then and you certainly aren’t now – and the man you became isn’t the one he remembers, anymore than he is the man who you loved all those years ago! Did it ever occur to you that maybe he is just as frightened as you are, and as long as you hide away in this house, pushing him away because he ran from the enormity of it all, neither one of you will ever get to stop being afraid?” 

She caught herself then, realizing she had no place in this business and looked away. “You never once struck me as a man who would run from his problems. When I met you, not even the entire force of England could hold you back. Fear was the last thing in this world that could cripple you – to see it doing so now? It’s actually quite horrible.” And was it any wonder that people were worried, because of it?

we’ve finally cracked the code lads the real reason flint decided silver was a viable work partner in s2 is because he looks like a poodle and poodles=friendship/thomas

image

“Poodles are horrendous animals and this is a horrifying implication. This is me. Horrified. I wear this wig because I have to – because I pay to look this ridiculous as part of my fee for being annoyingly well off. Which is worse by far than being cursed to look this hideous naturally.”